ARTICLE
Punch
March 25, 2025
5 Min read

A great product sells itself. Branding is unnecessary.

MYTH-BUSTED
Even the best product can vanish into obscurity without a brand to give it voice, meaning, and memorability.
ARTICLE
Punch
March 25, 2025
5 Min read
Category
Myth Buster

Too many great ideas have died quietly—not because they weren’t brilliant, but because no one knew how to brand them. Let’s bust one of the most dangerous myths in business.

Many entrepreneurs and business owners hold the belief that if a product is exceptional, it will naturally find an audience and succeed without the need for branding.

The idea is that quality alone will drive word-of-mouth marketing, generate demand, and establish a strong customer base.

However, while product quality is undeniably important, relying on it alone is a risky strategy.

Branding is what transforms a product from just another option into a must-have.

Without it, even the best innovations can go unnoticed, struggle with customer loyalty, and fail to differentiate themselves in an increasingly crowded marketplace.

Let’s break down this myth and explore why branding is not just necessary but essential for a great product to achieve long-term success.

The Reality: Branding gives products meaning and market relevance

A great product does not exist in a vacuum. Consumers are constantly bombarded with choices, and without a clear, compelling brand, even an outstanding product can struggle to make an impact.

Branding is more than a logo or a catchy slogan—it’s the story, perception, and emotional connection that surrounds a product. It’s what makes consumers choose your product over a competitor’s, even if both have similar quality.

Why branding is indispensable

Brand awareness: People can’t buy what they don’t know exists

No matter how great a product is, if people aren’t aware of it, they won’t buy it. The market is saturated with options, and unless a product is effectively branded and marketed, it risks being ignored.

  • Example: Dyson’s vacuum cleaners were technologically superior, but they didn’t gain traction until a strong branding strategy positioned them as the premium, innovative choice. The brand’s focus on design, engineering, and problem-solving made Dyson a household name, despite competitors offering similar functionality.

Differentiation: Standing out in a crowded market

Branding is what separates a product from being just another alternative. It creates a unique identity that makes it easier for consumers to recognize and prefer one product over another.

  • Example: Water is one of the most basic products, yet brands like Fiji, Evian, and Smartwater have successfully positioned themselves as premium options through branding. The water itself may not be drastically different, but the branding elevates the product’s perceived value.

Without branding, products risk being generic commodities, forcing them into a price war where the lowest price wins. Branding ensures that people choose a product based on more than just cost.

Emotional connection: Branding creates loyalty

A product may be great, but what keeps customers coming back is the emotional connection they have with the brand. Branding builds relationships, trust, and a sense of belonging, which encourages repeat purchases and long-term loyalty.

  • Example: Apple’s iPhone isn’t just a high-quality smartphone—it’s a symbol of innovation, creativity, and status. Many customers stick with Apple not just for the product, but because they identify with the brand’s ethos and community.

A strong brand makes customers feel like they are part of something bigger than just a transaction.

The myth in action: Why good products fail without branding

History is filled with incredible products that failed because they lacked proper branding. Here are a few notable cases:

Betamax:
Great Quality, Wrong Format

Background:

In the early days of home video, two formats competed to dominate living rooms: Sony’s Betamax and JVC’s VHS. Both allowed people to record TV and watch movies from the comfort of their homes.

The Product:

Betamax was the better-quality format. It offered sharper images and more compact tapes.

Early Product Ads for Sony Betamax
Early product Ads for Sony Betamax
Why It Failed:

Critical flaw: early Betamax tapes could only record up to one hour, while VHS tapes offered two hours or more, enough to fit an entire movie on one tape. VHS provided a better home movie experience, people wanted to watch full films without switching tapes.

Partnerships: JVC licensed VHS to other companies, making it more affordable and widely available. VHS also secured better partnerships with movie studios and video rental stores, so more titles were available in VHS format.

  • Sony, meanwhile, kept Betamax tightly controlled and didn’t adapt quickly enough to consumer preferences.
Takeaway:

Even with a superior product, Betamax lost because it didn’t deliver the full experience people wanted.

Lesson: Understand your customer’s lifestyle—and make it easy for them to say yes. Branding and accessibility beat specs.

Google Glass: The Product with No Clear Purpose

Background:

In 2013, Google Glass hit the market with a bold vision: smart glasses that could show information, take photos, and respond to voice commands—all hands-free. It was futuristic and exciting.

The Product:

Google Glass was a wearable computer, blending augmented reality and real-world interaction. Technologically, it was impressive. But it came with no clear message about who it was for or why it existed.

model using oogle glass - AI generated
Google glass - Concept illustration created using AI technology.
Why It Failed:
  • No clear audience: Was it for tech geeks? doctors? cyclists? creatives? The use case was never defined.
  • Privacy concerns: People didn’t like being recorded without knowing it, leading to public backlash.
  • Poor social acceptance: Users were labeled “Glass-holes,” and the product felt more awkward than empowering.
  • Google didn’t tell a compelling brand story: There was no emotional connection or lifestyle narrative to win people over.
Takeaway:

Innovation alone isn’t enough. Without a focused purpose and emotional appeal, even brilliant ideas can feel irrelevant.

Lesson: Clarity of audience and story are just as important as cutting-edge tech.

Crystal Pepsi: A Cool Idea with No Substance

Background:

In the early 1990s, Pepsi launched Crystal Pepsi—a clear, caffeine-free cola aimed at health-conscious consumers during the rise of “clean” products. It looked different, and that was the point.

The Product:

Crystal Pepsi was basically Pepsi without the color or caffeine, designed to feel “pure” and modern. It stood out on shelves—but that’s where it ended.

Crystal Pepsi - Concept illustration created using AI technology.
Why It Failed:
  • No clear reason to exist—Pepsi never explained why it was clear or why that mattered.
  • Weak emotional hook—consumers weren’t sure if it was healthier, lighter, or just a gimmick.
  • It confused loyal customers, and didn’t attract enough new ones.
  • The brand story didn’t match the experience, and people quickly moved on.
Takeaway:

Looking different doesn’t matter if you can’t explain why it matters. Without a strong identity and message, people don’t connect.

Lesson: A product needs more than a cool idea—it needs a clear story, a reason to care, and a brand people can believe in

The power of branding in making a product successful

Let’s look at how branding has played a crucial role in turning products into household names:

Nike: Selling a lifestyle, not just shoes

Nike’s shoes are well-made, but their branding is what makes them an industry leader. The “Just Do It” slogan, powerful storytelling, and endorsements from top athletes have turned Nike into more than just a footwear brand—it’s a movement.

Nike’s branding creates an emotional connection with consumers, making them feel like they’re part of an elite group of achievers and athletes.

That’s why people are willing to pay premium prices for Nike products instead of cheaper alternatives.

Tesla: Branding innovation, not just cars

Tesla didn’t just sell electric cars—it sold the vision of the future. Elon Musk positioned Tesla as a cutting-edge technology company, not just an automaker.

By branding Tesla as revolutionary, the company has been able to attract a cult-like following and create high demand, despite the presence of other electric car manufacturers.

Tesla’s branding turns customers into loyal advocates who don’t just buy the cars—they promote the brand.

Coca-Cola: Selling happiness

Coca-Cola doesn’t market itself as just a soda—it sells an experience.

The brand has spent decades associating itself with happiness, togetherness, and nostalgia through powerful advertising campaigns.

Even though there are countless cola options, Coca-Cola remains the leader because of its strong brand identity.

Why businesses should invest in branding. No matter how great the product

Branding is what makes a product:

— Recognizable:

In a cluttered marketplace, like today, attention is scarce. Branding creates visual and emotional cues that help your product stand out and be instantly identifiable.

From a distinctive logo to a consistent voice, branding ensures that consumers know exactly who you are, often at just a glance. This recognizability builds familiarity and trust over time.

— Memorable:

Consumers are bombarded with options daily. A strong brand goes beyond the transaction and lodges itself in the customer’s mind through storytelling, experience, and emotion.

Whether it’s a jingle, a slogan, a brand color, or a compelling narrative, these brand assets work together to ensure people don’t just see your product, they remember it.

— Valuable:

A well-branded product can charge a premium, not because it costs more to make, but because the brand creates perceived value. People are willing to pay more for what they trust, relate to, and admire.

Branding builds that emotional connection, transforming a product from a commodity into a must-have item. Over time, this loyalty reduces customer acquisition costs and increases lifetime value.

How to build a strong brand around a great product

1. Develop a clear brand identity

Define what your brand stands for beyond the product itself. This includes articulating your mission (your “why”), your values (what you believe in), and your personality (how your brand expresses itself).

A clear identity helps internal teams stay aligned and gives your audience something to connect with. When people understand who you are and what you stand for, they’re more likely to trust and support your brand.

Tip: Ask yourself—if your brand were a person, how would it talk, act, and make decisions?

2. Craft a Compelling Brand Story

People don’t just buy products—they buy into stories. Your brand story should explain your journey, what inspired the creation of your product, and the problem it solves in a way that feels human and relatable.

A great story helps audiences emotionally invest in your brand and share it with others, building organic advocacy.

Think: Why does your brand exist beyond making a profit? That’s your story.

3. Create a Consistent Visual Identity

Visual consistency builds recognition and trust. From your logo and color palette to your typography, photography style, and packaging design, every visual element should reflect your brand’s essence.

A cohesive look ensures that customers instantly associate visual cues with your brand—online, in-store, or on social media.

Consistency doesn’t mean boring—it means unmistakably you, everywhere you show up.

4. Engage in meaningful marketing

Marketing isn’t just about visibility—it’s about resonance. Use your brand voice and positioning to craft messaging that truly connects with your ideal audience. Tailor your campaigns to reflect your brand’s values and voice across digital channels, ads, content, and experiences.

When your marketing is aligned with your brand, it builds recognition and trust, not just reach.

Right message + right audience + right timing = real impact.

5. Foster customer relationships

Loyalty isn’t built through transactions, it’s built through trust and connection. Create opportunities for ongoing engagement with your audience: share behind-the-scenes content, invite feedback, personalize experiences, and show that you care.

The stronger the emotional connection, the more likely customers are to become long-term advocates of your brand.

A customer who feels connected to your brand is worth more than ten who don’t.

Key takeaways

The belief that “a great product sells itself” is a dangerous myth that has led many businesses to failure.

In today’s competitive market, branding is essential for making a product visible, desirable, and valuable.

A strong brand not only attracts customers but also keeps them loyal, ensuring long-term success.

Without branding, even the best products can fade into obscurity.

If you want your product to succeed, don’t rely on quality alone—invest in branding. It’s the difference between being an unknown product and becoming an unforgettable brand.

the workbook

The secret to digital success!
Employ brand consistency. Build customer trust. Maximize your ROI and drive sales.

You're awesome!

We've got your request, and your Workbook is en route to your inbox.

Psst! Don't forget to check your spam folder, just in case :-)
Learn more about Punch
Oops!
Something went wrong while submitting the form. Can you try one more time?